《Journal of Responsible Technology》:An exploratory thematic review of the emerging field of RRI education
本探索性主题综述审视了负责任的研究与创新(Responsible Research and Innovation,RRI)教育的新兴格局。研究人员回顾了过去二十年间发表的17项同行评议研究,采用PRISMA(Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses)方法学。这些研究被划分为四个主题,以识别反复出现的成功实践与障碍。综述强调了若干成功实践,包括RRI的情境化、反思性(reflexivity)的提升、参与式方法、跨学科合作,以及制度整合的实例。同时,综述揭示了持续存在的障碍,如概念模糊性、制度阻力、可扩展性限制,以及将抽象RRI原则转化为可测量能力的困难。部分障碍之间的关联表明存在一种恶性强化循环,阻碍了RRI教育的发展。研究人员认为,解决概念和定义上的模糊性可能促进更连贯、更可持续的RRI教育。
本研究主体部分围绕探索性主题综述展开,系统分析了RRI教育领域的现有实践、挑战与模式。
**3.1 描述性研究(Descriptive Studies)**
该分类包含三项研究,主要记录和分析RRI在教育环境中的现有实践、原则与背景,旨在提供基础性理解而非测试或评估干预措施。
这批研究在促进批判性思维、深化对科学技术社会影响的认识方面取得成功,其关键促进因素包括RRI教育的情境化、弥合理论与实践之间的鸿沟,以及鼓励积极参与现实社会科学问题。然而,研究也识别出显著障碍,如有限的制度认可、资源约束,以及无法评估或衡量长期影响。此外,研究强调需要更系统、更连贯的RRI教育方法。
Levikov等(2020)在马耳他大学的研究采用两阶段形成性研究:第一阶段通过访谈和问卷调查理解RRI的本土语境;第二阶段创建RRI最佳实践文化并建立关键支持人物。该项目通过"参与式研究委员会"等可操作框架,展示了本地化举措如何促进更广泛的文化转变。但有限的制度认可和资源约束凸显了扩大此类努力的系统性障碍。
Elster等(2020)在不来梅大学生物学与化学系的研究展示了通过参与式和反思性实践嵌入RRI的路径。其"公民-SIP模型"(Citizen-SIP Model)作为一种参与式评估工具,通过让学生参与现实社会科学问题,有效提升了学生对RRI的理解,培养了批判性思维并增强了对科学社会影响的认识。成功整合的模块包括纳米技术风险素养以及生物多样性丧失和气候变化等伦理困境。但将该模型扩展到更大、更多样化的学生群体存在后勤挑战,其实施的资源密集性以及缺乏对培训长期影响的评估可能限制广泛采用。
Schuijff和Dijkstra(2019)系统分析了79项RRI实践,锚定于利益相关者参与、预期、反思性和回应性等核心维度。研究强调了使研究与需求和价值观对齐的重要性,同时识别出协作、适应性和制度支持等成功因素。但该综述揭示出方法论不一致、长期影响评估有限,以及RRI原则向制度结构整合不足等显著缺陷,强调需要更系统、更连贯的方法将RRI嵌入研究实践。
**3.2 综述研究(Review Studies)**
该分类包含四项研究,评估RRI教育或实施的有效性、成果和更广泛影响,突出有前景的实践和持续挑战。
参与式方法通过让学生和公民参与塑造结果,显示出增强反思性和社会对齐的潜力。将RRI与教育哲学联系的结构化框架以及结合定性与定量方法的多维学习评估显示出改进RRI教育的希望。然而,评估反思性、伦理意识和社会影响仍然困难。这些研究还报告了伦理和性别问题的代表性不足、资源限制阻碍参与式和探索性方法,以及优先短期成果而牺牲长期可持续性的倾向,削弱了RRI对齐的深度。
Bardone等(2023)论证了将RRI与现有哲学(科学本质、探究式学习、社会科学议题、公民教育)建立联系的必要性,尽管这种联系已经存在,但需要对RRI有更全面、更连贯的理解。这与更广泛的文献模式一致:多项研究报告了概念模糊性(如RRI是经验性的、规范性的还是程序性的),以及将其转化为可教、可评估学习成果的困难,包括区分科学推理与伦理反思的挑战。RRI映射研究建议通过将RRI映射与现有教育哲学联系,克服碎片化并获得对科学教育中RRI的连贯理解,使RRI在教育中更具相关性。
Stahl等(2023)聚焦负责任创新(RI)和RRI的培训与评估,承认其概念区别但尚在发展之中。虽然RRI原则的培训获得广泛支持,但对其内容、交付和评估尚未达成共识。研究提出了关键问题,如RRI中谁承担责任、它是认知性的还是经验性的,以及培训如何解决内部张力。研究强调有效培训和评估的基本要素,包括概念清晰性、定性与定量方法的平衡,以及透明评估标准与建设性反馈。但研究认为不存在适用于所有机构和学科的普遍评估方法,并强调测量反思性和伦理意识等复杂能力,以及使用传统指标评估社会影响和长期伦理参与的挑战。
Heras和Ruiz-Mallén(2017)开发了用于科学教育中青年参与者的分析框架,其对齐于教学实践。该框架包括认知方面(知识获取、概念理解)、经验方面(情感、态度、参与)、横向能力(反思性思维、协作、沟通)和RRI维度(包容性、伦理意识、性别平等)的指标。对72项研究的回顾揭示了对定量方法(如封闭式问卷)的依赖,限制了对经验和情感学习的洞察。虽然混合方法更好地捕捉了RRI的多维性质,但定性方法未得到充分利用。研究强调将评估指标与RRI过程要求相联系,倡导整合认知、情感和伦理学习维度的整体评估。挑战包括时间和资源约束、偏爱标准化评估的课程压力,以及测量伦理和反思性等抽象概念的困难。认知学习是最常被评估的,而伦理和性别问题以及情感参与往往被忽视。
Vestergaard Bidstrup等(2024)通过将公民反馈纳入政策制定,展示了对RRI及RRI教育语境的更好理解机会,同时增强了获得公众信任和问责的机会。研究涉及希腊西马其顿和保加利亚索非亚市两个地区,分别有23名和27名公民参与小组,代表不同人口群体以确保广泛的社会代表性。公民提供了改进地区政策的宝贵见解,引入伦理、回应性和包容性等常被初始政策提案忽视的RRI要素。但该研究也存在挑战:小组仅限于单日活动,可能限制审议深度和反馈范围;公民优先短期财务和社会利益,有时忽视长期或更广泛的可持续性目标;某些RRI原则如性别平等受到极少关注。
**3.3 干预研究(Intervention Studies)**
该分类包含四项研究,提出并测试将RRI原则嵌入研究、教育和政策制定的新方法、途径或干预措施。
这些研究强调促进对假设、价值和社会维度的反思以促进更深层次理解和变革性学习的重要性,也展示了跨学科互动如何增强对RRI的理解和应用。通过结构化框架将科学教育与社会挑战联系,有助于将RRI能力映射到教育环境中,使学习与现实应用对齐。参与式方法增强了协作和包容性,有效将教育与社会价值整合。将RRI嵌入治理和合规机制的制度框架提供了超越项目资金的长期可持续性潜力。然而,关于RRI定义和范围的持续争论阻碍了持续整合,资源密集的方法论面临更广泛教育环境中的可扩展性问题。优先即时成果而非长期影响仍然是一个重大挑战。
Malagrida等(2022)将STEAM(Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts and Mathematics)教育能力映射到八个RRI关联类别的框架中。通过教师焦点小组,使用虚拟实验、卡片游戏和社区参与式研究(Community-Based Participatory Research,CBPR)等现有教育工具评估RRI能力。教师强调RRI在连接科学教育和社会挑战方面的作用,但挑战也随之出现:部分资源未能全面解决RRI能力,如区分科学问题与伦理问题或预期社会影响;学生经常难以批判性分析科学证据;并非所有工具都同样有效(CBPR比虚拟实验更好地促进反思性,但面临后勤障碍);教师需要进一步培训以促进讨论和利益相关者参与。
Lukovics等(2019)强调早期将RRI整合到研究发展创新(Research Development Innovation,RDI)中以加强其同化的重要性。研究改编了社会技术整合研究(Socio-Technical Integration Research,STIR)方法,鼓励在研究过程中进行跨学科对话和对社会影响的反思。前后问卷显示意识、反思性和更广泛智力参与的增加。挑战包括学生对整合非科学因素的最初抵制、STIR密集型性质导致的可扩展性问题、缺乏长期影响评估,以及影响可复制性的促进者依赖。
Stahl等(2021)探索从基于项目的RRI向更嵌入式模型"通过设计实现责任"(Responsibility by Design,RbD)的过渡。该方法源于人类大脑项目(Human Brain Project,HBP)中八年的RRI实施,整合了RRI AREA框架(由Stilgoe、Owen和Macnaghten于2013年提出)。成功包括公众参与塑造项目决策、伦理指南的发展,以及将RRI原则嵌入跨学科协作、治理和合规。但RRI定义和范围的持续争论、学科差异导致的对齐困难、法律和合规要求遮蔽更广泛的RRI目标、确保项目后RRI延续的困难,以及评估RRI长期文化影响的概念和实践挑战仍然存在。
Hesjedal等(2020)倡导从程序合规向变革性理解的转变,引入双环学习(double-loop learning),挑战基本假设而非强化现有程序。该反思性方法旨在使RRI教育更具适应性和自我批判性。研究分析了生物技术领域早期职业研究人员的博士课程,检验其如何鼓励参与者反思实践、价值和理论假设。课程成功创造了"突破",促进了对科学社会维度和研究中社会角色作用的更深认识。但许多参与者难以表达学习成果或在日常工作中应用,有些人发现难以理解RRI和双环学习,强化了不存在将RRI转化为能力的直接方式的论点。
**3.4 概念研究(Conceptual Studies)**
该分类包含六项研究,寻求将RRI框架扩展到新语境,为更广泛和更可持续的应用提供实践策略。
许多概念研究成功地将RRI原则纳入问题式学习、共同创造等教育方法,促进跨学科协作,包括科学哲学与纳米医学的整合以及多元利益相关者培训。其他研究为公众参与和RRI实施开发了定制指标,使其与特定地区或学科需求对齐。这些努力促进了批判性反思和反思性,使参与者能够评估其工作的伦理和社会维度。然而,RRI仍然资源密集、耗时且依赖高水平专业知识。扩大参与式和反思性方法至更广泛语境存在挑战,RRI缺乏清晰、标准化的定义使持续实施复杂化。此外,一些研究报告了研究人员和参与者对整合社会伦理等非传统方面的抵制,制度奖励系统继续优先传统研究产出而非RRI实践。
Mejlgaard等(2019)借鉴亚里士多德伦理学,通过培养实践智慧(phronesis)推进RRI教育,帮助学生在复杂、不确定的语境中自信地应对伦理困境。研究基于访谈和政策审查,探讨在高等教育中培养RRI文化。研究识别出关键RUI相关能力,包括批判性反思、真实案例整合和外部行动者参与,强调问题式学习(Problem-Based Learning,PBL)、探究式学习(Inquiry-Based Learning,IBL)和新苏格拉底对话在让学生接触科学社会影响方面的有效性。但采用实践智慧视角的障碍包括资源密集性、优先传统研究产出的学术奖励系统,以及对教育者个人经验的高度依赖。
Sandu等(2021)将共同创造和创造力整合到RRI教育中,使用真实案例研究连接社会和科学领域。研究探索了学校和科学合作的作用,强调学习者、教师、科学家和社会行动者的积极参与,使研究与价值观对齐。案例研究包括遗产教育的数字故事讲述、社区共同创造和开放学校倡议。定性评估显示学生发展了更大的创造力、批判性思维和团队协作技能。但该研究也识别出挑战:学生面临获取适当数字工具和技术专长的困难,许多人最初不愿采用创造性和参与性方法,需要额外促进;方法论的资源密集性限制了在不同教育环境中的可扩展性;教师需要进一步培训以在提供结构和培养创造性自主性之间取得平衡。
Marschalek等(2017)开发了面向政策制定者、教育者、研究人员、公民社会和行业代表等多元利益相关者群体的互动式反思培训项目。培训培养了对RRI原则的共同理解,使参与者能够通过定制方法反思和实施这些概念。培训后反馈显示参与者感到更有能力在各自语境中应对RRI,许多人描述了促使其整合RRI原则的" energizing effect"。但研究也识别出挑战:参与者现有知识和参与意愿的差异需要定制化培训方法;RRI的广泛抽象性质使一些参与者难以完全理解和实施其原则;招募和确保多元利益相关者群体的积极参与资源密集且复杂;虽然互动式、实践式方法证明有效,但将其扩展到更大群体或不同地区面临重大挑战。
Portillo等(2022)寻求通过工具和活动(如Moral-IT卡片和ORBIT RRI自我评估)支持研究人员应用RRI原则,并共同创建针对数字和自主系统研究(包括个人数据的伦理使用)的RRI实施指南。访谈和研讨会讨论显示,参与者赞赏RRI聚焦会话的价值,Moral-IT等工具促进了有意义的讨论和对潜在研究影响的预期,研究人员开发了将RRI整合到工作流程中的可操作策略。但障碍也存在:项目持续时间短使全面实施RRI原则变得困难,特别是需要大量反思和协作的活动;大多数参与者先前对RRI接触有限,导致理解和应用的不均衡;ORBIT RRI自我评估等工具耗时且并非总是针对具体项目语境定制;研究人员缺乏足够的制度支持,如RRI相关努力的认可或促进这些实践的专职角色。
Oftedal(2014)主张将科学哲学整合到RRI框架中,强调其在审视科学基本假设方面的作用,特别是在纳米医学领域。研究分析了纳米医学实践中的主导还原论方法,聚焦于分子水平原因而忽视疾病因果中的系统性或更高层次因素。研究强调了还原论建模的伦理风险,如过度简化疾病因果,可能导致患者与其健康责任的疏离。但将这些视角整合到实践RRI框架中证明具有挑战性,因其抽象性质和被认为缺乏直接适用性;纳米医学中主导还原论范式的抵制,以及科学哲学家的自然科学家之间有限的互动,进一步阻碍了更广泛视角的采用。
García-Melón等(2022)通过成熟度框架扩展了对技术中心(Technological Centres,TCs)RRI制度化的评估,提供了对未来实施有启发的见解。研究使用层次分析法(Analytic Hierarchy Process,AHP)方法,通过参与式会议和决策工具确保利益相关者所有权,提供了指标的定量排名。迭代反馈确认了指标的相关性和适用性,研究开发了20项反映独有优先事项(政策、共同创造和能力建设)的指标,并通过多标准决策方法确定了七项优先实施的关键指标。但研究也识别出挑战:利益相关者观点的差异导致政策相关指标优先级不一致;聚合层次(微观与宏观)的差异使比较复杂化;虽然该方法在有效,但需要针对更广泛和国际语境进行调整;单独定量指标不足以捕捉公众参与的质量方面,如其深度或社会影响。
**4. 综合分析**
**4.1 成功实施的主题**
综述识别出五项成功实施的主题。情境化(14/17项研究)最为成功,指将RRI能力映射到特定教育或地区环境,创建与现实应用和社会挑战对齐的框架。反思性和反思性(12/17)指促进批判性思维和反思性,使参与者能够评估其工作的伦理和社会维度。参与式方法(11/17)指让利益相关者、学生和公民参与共同创造过程,增强包容性并使研究和教育 glycol 格式化误不匹配预期]的需要对齐。跨学科合作(9/17)指弥合学科如哲学与科学和利益相关者参与之间的鸿沟,丰富视角并嵌入RRI原则。制度整合(6/17)指将RRI原则嵌入治理和合规机制以提供超越项目资金的可持续性,但成功率最低。
**4.2 障碍**
综述识别出六项障碍主题。资源密集性和可扩展性(10/17)指RRI教育方法对时间、促进和专业知识的高需求,特别是涉及参与式和反思性部分,限制了其可扩展性。制度和文化的障碍(13/17)指RRI实践的制度认可有限以及偏向传统产出的学术奖励系统,阻碍更广泛的采用和可持续性。定义和概念挑战(12/17)指RRI含义及其与科学本质、科学哲学及相关框架区别的持续模糊性,破坏了持续整合和理解。短期关注与长期影响(10/17)指教育干预中对即时成果的强调,使RRI培训的长期社会、制度或行为效应未得到评估或支持。能力发展挑战(5/17)指参与者难以表达和实践应用RRI概念,强调将RRI转化为具体能力的困难。测量和评估挑战(9/17)指现有指标难以捕捉RRI教育的定性、长期和往往抽象的成果,如伦理意识、反思性或社会回应性。
**4.3 成功与障碍之间的|--}
Paragraph 4.3 introduces the concept of ambivalent dynamics. Researchers note that several factors identified as successes also appear as obstacles under different conditions. Institutional integration is typically viewed positively—signaling the inclusion of RRI in curricula, strategy documents, and project design—but it may also become a barrier when it leads to bureaucratic formalization, tokenistic compliance, or rigid assessment frameworks that undermine reflexivity. Similarly, interdisciplinary collaboration is celebrated as a driver of innovation, yet it also creates tension dueowing to differing epistemic traditions and communication styles. These examples illustrate that RRI education advances through ambivalent dynamics, in which enabling structures may also constrain transformative learning. Recognizing these dualities helps explain why progress remains uneven and how the field becomes caught in a self-reinforcing cycle of partial success and persistent limitation. These ambivalent dynamics form the basis of a vicious reinforcing cycle in RRI education.
Paragraph 4.4 focuses specifically on conceptual and philosophical ambiguity. It emphasizes that a shared root of many challenges is the unclear conceptual and philosophical foundation of RRI—what it is, what kind of knowledge it represents, and its relationship to scientific inquiry. Notably, definitional and conceptual uncertainty appears as a barrier in at least 12 of 17 studies, frequently coexisting with assessment and competency development difficulties. Without a clear epistemological and ethical foundation, educational initiatives stay fragmented, producing short-lived successes that rarely translate into institutional or behavioral change. The review identifies three dominant interpretative strands in the literature:
- First, RRI as a strategy for mutually responsive stakeholders anticipating research and innovation outcomes to address "grand challenges," yet this presumes challenges are knowable and outcomes predictable, which from a philosophy of science perspective—particularly informed by fallibilism and complex systems theory—is problematic. Scientific and technological trajectories are often unpredictable, nonlinear, and emergent. This risks instrumentalizing science, reducing it to a tool for solving predefined societal problems, and downplaying epistemic autonomy and the exploratory nature of scientific inquiry.
- Second, RRI as a policy-driven framework introduced by the European Commission in the early 2010s, emphasizing inclusive and sustainable research and innovation through co-creation and co-production with society. Yet this risks normative paternalism, assuming values and needs can be clearly identified and agreed upon, contradicting philosophical insights into value-laden and contestable nature of science. It encourages conformity over critique, potentially muting scientific dissent or radical innovation challenging current societal values, and reflects a linear governance model assuming values can be translated into research agendas without loss or distortion.
- Third, the perspective where stakeholder inclusion, participation, and partnership foster harmony and consensus by reducing divergent judgments and values to shared understanding. This implies ethical pluralism should be reduced through stakeholder dialogue, yet this can be counterproductive. It treats ethical disagreement as something to manage away rather than a productive force, and depends on deliberative idealism, assuming dialogue naturally leads to shared ethics, overlooking power dynamics, strategic behavior, and incommensurable worldviews.
This lack of philosophical grounding creates a vicious reinforcing cycle. Ambiguous definitions lead to inconsistent curricula and assessment criteria, undermining institutional recognition and resource allocation. Weak institutionalization then prevents long-term investment in conceptual development, perpetuating the very ambiguity impeding progress. This cycle links definitional vagueness, methodological inconsistency, and institutional inertia into a self-sustaining loop. Engaging explicitly with philosophy of science offers a pathway out by clarifying how responsibility, reflexivity, and scientific reasoning interrelate, enabling more consistent pedagogy and institutional embedding.
**5. Conclusions and Future Research**
The review concludes that RRI education is conceptually fragmented and methodologically diverse. A recurring theme is the lack of definitional and philosophical clarity about what RRI entails, how it relates to existing educational paradigms, and what kinds of knowledge and competencies it should cultivate. Several studies reported uncertainty about whether RRI should be approached as an/extension] an empirical, normative, or procedural framework, while others highlighted educators' difficulty distinguishing scientific from ethical reasoning. This persistent conceptual ambiguity underpins many practical challenges.
Only a subset of included studies explicitly propose that philosophy of science could strengthen RRI education's conceptual and institutional foundations, yet the underlying problem—conceptual ambiguity and its downstream effects on pedagogy, assessment, and institutional embedding—recurs across reviewed literature. A small number of studies demonstrated that introducing explicit philosophical reasoning strengthens both conceptual coherence and educational depth. Oftedal (2014) showed engaging the philosophy of science can reveal hidden epistemic assumptions in research practices, broadening RRI's ethical and conceptual foundations. Mejlgaard et al. (2019) illustrated teaching RRI through a phronetic, or practical-wisdom-based, approach helps learners navigate moral complexity and link theoretical reflection with professional decision-making. Bardone, Burget and Pedaste (2023) argued mapping RRI within established educational philosophies such as the Nature of Science framework increases its intelligibility and legitimacy. These findings collectively suggest that recurring obstacles in RRI education—conceptual vagueness, weak institutional integration, and inconsistent competence development—stem from insufficient philosophical grounding. Therefore, systematically integrating philosophy of science into RRI education seems a promising direction, not as a standalone philosophy curriculum but as a pedagogical support embedded in existing RRI teaching practices to make core distinctions and learning outcomes teachable and assessable. Philosophical reflection offers analytical tools to clarify RRI's epistemological status, articulate its normative dimensions, and reconcile tensions between scientific autonomy and societal accountability. This would not replace existing pedagogical models but rather provide the conceptual support that connects them, enabling more coherent curricula, more reliable assessment, and more sustainable institutional support.
--}Paragraph 5.2 acknowledges limitations. This exploratory thematic synthesis of an emerging field, based on 17 peer-reviewed studies over two decades, should be read as identifying recurring patterns rather than providing definitive estimates of prevalence or effectiveness. Findings depend on included studies' reporting quality. The search strategy may have excluded relevant work, particularly non-English publications and grey literature. The corpus is dominated by European contexts, limiting global generalisability given RRI's strong linkage to European policy frameworks. The inductive categorisation and thematic clustering involve interpretive judgement; alternative categorisations could foreground different relationships between studies.
Paragraph 5.3 outlines future research directions. The field would benefit from broadening evidence coverage by extending searches to additional databases, non-English outlets, and grey literature. Improved reporting and comparability through clearer reporting conventions would enable stronger cross-study synthesis. Further work should diversify geographical contexts through studies outside Europe and explicitly comparative designs. Longitudinal designs and follow-up measurements are needed to determine whether RRI education yields sustained behavioral, institutional, or policy effects beyond project timelines. Research should incorporate practitioner and learner perspectives through interviews, participatory inquiry, or co-analysis. These advances should be coupled with empirical testing of pedagogical supports, such as mapping RRI to established educational paradigms, competency-based rubrics, tool-supported reflection, and philosophical or epistemic supports. Future research should examine how Philosophy of Science based instruction can operationalize reflexivity, anticipation, and inclusiveness as measurable competencies across disciplines.