《Frontiers in Psychology》:The role of telehealth models, including teleneuropsychology, in assessing decision-making capacity in older adults with cognitive impairments: a scoping review
Abstract
Objective:
Decision-making capacity (DMC) evaluations are decision-specific and typically rely on integrated evidence from interview-based assessments of decisions, functional abilities, collateral history, and behavioural observations, with cognitive testing providing supportive (non-determinative) evidence. Telehealth models, including teleneuropsychology (tele-NP), have potential to expand access to capacity-related assessments for older adults with cognitive impairments who cannot attend in-person services, but its use for DMC assessments remains unclear. This scoping review mapped how telehealth has been used to support DMC assessments, explicitly or implicitly, in older adults with cognitive impairments and summarised feasibility, validity/reliability, and implementation considerations.
Method:
A scoping review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA-ScR guidance. Five databases were searched from inception to 05 January 2026. Studies were eligible if they involved older adults with cognitive impairments (aged ≥65?years) and used telehealth for assessment processes that either evaluated DMC (Tier A), or informed capacity-adjacent decisions (e.g. driving, living alone, guardianship planning; Tier B).
Results:
The search produced 1,738 results; a total of 1,264 records were screened, and 102 full-text articles were retrieved for further review. Five studies met inclusion criteria, three of which were classified as Tier A for at least one patient. The remaining two studies primarily involved telehealth cognitive, geriatric, or psychiatric assessments that informed capacity-adjacent recommendations but did not operationalise DMC as a primary outcome. All telehealth models were supported by additional staff, with onsite staff supporting technology and, in some cases, components of the assessments. Reported opportunities included improved access and timeliness; barriers included sensory impairment, variable infrastructure, and limited reporting in tele-specific adaptations and decision-specific capacity procedures.
Conclusion:
Direct evidence for telehealth-delivered DMC assessments in older adults with cognitive impairments remains limited. Studies of telehealth capacity assessments involving tele-NP are even more limited. Future work should prioritise clear operationalisation and reporting of decision-specific DMC procedures, applied frameworks, guidelines and policies, as well as telehealth delivery models (including facilitation), and outcomes addressing feasibility, reliability/validity, and stakeholder acceptability. The necessity for tele-NP-specific normative data also needs to be evaluated.
1 Introduction
Decision-making capacity (DMC) refers to an individual’s ability to make a specific decision at a particular time. Four key consensus principles are typically applied when clinicallyassessing DMC across various clinical-legal frameworks, jurisdictions, settings and disciplines. These commonly take the form of determining a person’s ability to (1) understand relevant information, (2) appreciate how that information applies to their circumstances, (3) reason about options and consequences, and (4) communicate a stable choice. DMC is therefore risk-, decision- and time- specific, and it may fluctuate with delirium, psychiatric symptoms, medication effects, and changes in medical status. In older adults with cognitive impairments, DMC assessments often require careful attention to communication and functional barriers (e.g. aphasia, hearing/vision impairment), cultural and educational factors, and the availability and reliability of collateral information. It is consistently argued that emotion and personal values should also be considered component aspects of clinical assessments for DMC.
Assessing capacity can be an intensive and exacting process, with significant personal and legal consequences. It involves managing a nuanced balance between maintaining an individual’s autonomy and protecting them from apparent or potential neglect, abuse, risk, and exploitation. Clinicians are guided by various legal requirements, as well as discipline and professional standards, policy guidelines, and clinical frameworks when assessing an individual’s ability to make informed decisions. Neuropsychologists frequently contribute to capacity-related evaluations by detailing cognitive strengths and weaknesses (e.g. attention, memory, language, executive functioning) that may support or undermine decision-making abilities, and how this is impacting the decision-making process specific to the situation at hand. Cognitive impairment is one of the strongest predictors of impaired capacity. As such, largely because of an increased risk of developing cognitive impairments (e.g. dementia) and the impact of this on capacity, older adults can be particularly vulnerable to abuse and neglect. Importantly, though, cognitive test performance and/or neuropsychological functioning are not interpreted as a pass/fail threshold for capacity, nor should such be interpreted in isolation. Furthermore, there is no standalone test or evaluative tool that can determine someone’s capacity to make informed autonomous decisions. Capacity opinions are typically and by necessity based on an integrated synthesis of interview-based assessments of a specific decision, functional abilities, collateral history, and behavioural observations, with cognitive testing providing supportive evidence that helps explain why an individual may struggle with the decision demands; neuropsychologists typically receive training in the considered integration of all these areas over and above just completing cognitive testing. Professional competency codes and requirements regarding neuropsychology standards for capacity assessments are frequently recommended.
Translating capacity-related assessment processes to telehealth is potentially valuable, particularly for older adults living in rural areas, those with mobility limitations, and people who cannot attend in-person specialist services. Beyond access, telehealth may improve timeliness and enable greater standardisation through scripted protocols and structured documentation. However, capacity assessments present telehealth-specific challenges, including consent for the assessment, managing sensory impairment and communication supports, ensuring privacy, and clarifying which components are delivered remotely versus those facilitated onsite by staff. These issues are especially relevant because much telehealth work with older adults occurs in facilitated or hybrid models (e.g. rural hospitals or nursing facilities) rather than direct-to-home, unassisted assessment.
Accordingly, the aim of this scoping review was to map if and how tele-NP and related telehealth assessment models have been used to support DMC assessments in older adults with cognitive impairments, and to summarise feasibility, reliability/validity, and implementation considerations. This review focused specifically on older adults with cognitive impairments because dementia and age-related cognitive decline are among the most common clinical contexts in which DMC concerns arise. Additionally, telehealth-supported capacity assessment in younger populations may involve substantially different referral questions, etiologies, and service models, including acquired brain injury, intellectual disability, primary psychiatric conditions, and forensic contexts, which were outside the scope of the present review. While there are reviews exploring how tele-NP can facilitate the remote administration of cognitive assessments, including in older adults with cognitive impairments, there is no published review examining how capacity assessments have been and can be conducted using telehealth. We distinguished between studies that explicitly assessed DMC for defined decisions/domains (Tier A) and studies in which telehealth assessments informed capacity-adjacent recommendations but did not operationalise DMC as the primary outcome (Tier B).
2 Methods
2.1 Identifying the research question
The Population-Concept-Context (PCC) framework was used to identify the main concepts and search terms to help establish the following research questions:
- - Is tele-NP used to facilitate capacity assessments for older adults with cognitive impairments? If yes, is it an appropriate/valid method?
- - Does tele-NP have the potential to increase access to capacity assessments?
- - What are the potential opportunities for and barriers to the adoption of tele-NP capacity assessments?
2.2 Identifying the relevant studies
Relevant studies were shortlisted using the systematic search strategy described below and with the help of the PRISMA-ScR Checklist. This strategy was developed in consultation with a librarian at the University of Tasmania, Michaela Venn. Five databases – PubMed, PsycInfo, CINAHL, Web of Science and Google Scholar - were used to search for relevant literature. The concept of ‘older adults/aged’ was excluded from the search template to minimise the chance of missing studies that did not explicitly include these terms in the title/abstract and to account for the assumption that capacity assessments related to cognitive impairments are often conducted with older adults.
The database searches were initially conducted on 16 Apr 2024 and were updated on 05 Jan 2026 prior to submission to capture newly indexed records. The update used the same search strategy, restricted to records published/indexed from 2024 to 2026. For Google Scholar, only the first 200 records – sorted by relevance – were included in the full list of identified records; this is a number that has been identified to generate a 95% recall of relevant papers.
2.3 Study selection
All records were imported into Covidence for deduplication and screening. Titles/abstracts were screened against eligibility criteria by MVK, followed by full-text review. Studies were eligible if they involved older adults with cognitive impairments (average cohort age ≥65?years) and used telehealth for assessment processes that either evaluated DMC (Tier A), or informed capacity-adjacent decisions (e.g. driving, living alone, guardianship planning; Tier B).