Sustainable Valorization of Fish Waste into Bioenergy and Bioresources: A Critical Review of Technological Pathways, Challenges, and Integrated Biorefinery Prospects
《Fermentation》:Energy and Resource Conversion of Fish Waste: Current Status and Future Prospects
The global fish industry is an essential contributor to food security and the economy; however, it produces considerable quantities of fish waste. Depending on species and processing methods, 20–80% of fish biomass is discarded as waste, amounting to almost 64 million tons annually. Conventional disposal methods such as landfilling, incineration, and wastewater discharge cause environmental pollution and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Therefore, for sustainable development, it is important to valorize fish waste into renewable energy and value-added products. Hence, this review aims to encourage the technical development of fish waste into bioenergy and bioresources by thoroughly studying key technologies for converting it into biogas, biodiesel, fertilizer, animal feed, and biochar. Although several studies have explored these technologies, most remain disjointed and lack a systematic assessment. Therefore, this work attempted to critically evaluate the technological principles, advantages, limitations, and optimization strategies of current valorization approaches. Furthermore, several recommendations have been proposed, including conducting pilot-scale trials, producing higher value-added products within a biorefinery system. Overall, this review provides a holistic outlook on the energy and resource conversion of fish waste, supporting sustainable waste management.
**1. Introduction**
The global seafood industry constitutes a vital sector for food security, employment, and economic development, with worldwide production exceeding 180 million tonnes annually. Fish processing generates substantial quantities of by-products, including viscera, heads, bones, scales, skin, fins, and processing wastewater, the fraction of which depends strongly on species, product type, and processing intensity. These streams contain recoverable proteins, lipids, minerals, and organic matter, but inadequate management can contribute to odour, high oxygen demand, nutrient discharge, GHG emissions, and sanitary risks. In recent years, the concept of a circular bioeconomy has gained significant traction as a framework for sustainable waste management, wherein waste is viewed as a renewable resource capable of generating energy, materials, and chemicals. Fish waste is particularly amenable to biorefinery approaches because of its diverse and nutrient-dense composition: the high protein content makes it suitable for feed and fertilizer production, the lipid fraction is a promising feedstock for biodiesel, the mineral-rich bones and scales can be converted to biochar and phosphorus fertilizers, and the organic matter is highly biodegradable for biogas production. Despite extensive research on individual pathways, a comprehensive assessment is still needed to identify where each route is technically, environmentally, and economically most appropriate. This review therefore synthesizes process performance and limitations while explicitly considering feedstock heterogeneity, resource inputs, product value, scale-up barriers, and opportunities for integrated biorefineries.
**Fish Waste Heterogeneity as a Determinant of Process Selection**
Fish waste should not be treated as a uniform feedstock. Its moisture, protein, lipid, ash, salt, and mineral contents vary with fish species, age, season, capture or aquaculture conditions, processing method, storage time, and the specific fraction collected. Viscera and trimming residues are generally richer in readily degradable protein and lipids, whereas bones and scales contain more ash, calcium phosphate, and collagen; processing wastewater and sludge are substantially more dilute and may contain salt or cleaning chemicals. This variability directly affects route performance: high protein and low C/N ratios increase ammonia-inhibition risk during anaerobic digestion (AD), while lipid-rich fractions can improve methane or biodiesel potential but also increase long-chain fatty acid (LCFA) inhibition and oxidation sensitivity. Bone-rich fractions are better suited to phosphorus recovery, biochar, or mineral products, whereas fresh, hygienically controlled protein fractions may retain greater value as feed or protein hydrolysates. Seasonal changes in supply and composition also influence storage requirements, reactor loading, product consistency, and plant capacity utilization. Consequently, representative compositional characterization and feedstock segregation should precede route selection, and reported performance should be interpreted in relation to the actual waste fraction rather than generalized to fish waste as a whole.
**2. Fish Waste to Biogas**
**2.1 Fundamentals and Four-Stage Metabolic Pathway**
AD is the most technologically mature route for converting fish waste into renewable biogas. The process proceeds through four microbially mediated stages: hydrolysis, acidogenesis, acetogenesis, and methanogenesis. In hydrolysis, extracellular enzymes cleave proteins, lipids, and carbohydrates into soluble monomers. During acidogenesis, fermentative bacteria convert these monomers into volatile fatty acids (VFAs), alcohols, CO
2, H
2, and NH
3. Acetogenesis then oxidizes higher VFAs into acetate, CO
2, and H
2 under syntrophic association with hydrogenotrophic methanogens. Finally, methanogenesis produces CH
4 via acetoclastic and hydrogenotrophic pathways, yielding biogas typically containing 50–70% CH
4 and 30–50% CO
2. The biomethane potential of solid fish waste is considerable, reaching 300–500 mL/g VS under mesophilic conditions (35–38 °C, pH 6.8–7.5). However, the high biodegradability of fish waste is a double-edged sword: its low C/N ratio (3–7) and rapid protein hydrolysis predispose the system to ammonia accumulation and process instability.
**2.2 Key Inhibitory Challenges: Ammonia, Lipids, and Process Instability**
The stable operation of fish waste AD is governed by a constellation of interacting inhibitory factors. Ammonia toxicity is the principal constraint: rapid deamination of fish proteins releases NH
4+, which at elevated pH and temperature shifts to free NH
3, a membrane-permeant toxin that disrupts the proton motive force of methanogenic archaea. Mesophilic digestion is generally preferred, as thermophilic operation (50–55 °C), while kinetically faster, increases the NH
3 fraction and amplifies inhibition. Lipid accumulation poses a secondary challenge: fish viscera and heads release LCFAs that adsorb onto biomass, cause flotation, and inhibit methanogenesis. Furthermore, high salinity and residual H
2S from processing residues can exert additional stress. The interplay between rapid acidification (VFA accumulation), low buffering capacity, and ammonia toxicity often leads to reactor failure in mono-digestion systems.
**2.3 Mitigation Strategies for Anaerobic Digestion Inhibition**
To mitigate inhibition challenges in fish waste AD, two complementary strategies—co-digestion and pretreatment/additive enhancement—have been widely investigated. Co-digestion with carbon-rich substrates, including lignocellulosic biomass, agricultural residues, or manure, represents the most effective approach, as it adjusts the C/N ratio toward the optimal range (20–30), dilutes ammonia and LCFAs, and improves buffering capacity and microbial diversity. For instance, co-digestion of fish waste with water hyacinth using cow dung as inoculum significantly enhanced biogas production, while blending with waste activated sludge, whey and manure, or bagasse has demonstrated synergistic methane yields. Agricultural residues such as wheat straw and corn stover are particularly effective, providing structural support for microbial biofilms and reducing LCFA inhibition through adsorption. Beyond co-digestion, pretreatment and additive strategies can further accelerate hydrolysis and improve process stability. Thermal pretreatment (120–170 °C) disrupts protein tertiary structures and cell membranes, enhancing organic matter bioavailability, though excessive heating risks generating Maillard-derived recalcitrant compounds. Biochar-mediated enhancement has emerged as a particularly promising strategy: the addition of bamboo-derived hydrochar to fish waste AD significantly improved biogas yield by promoting direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET), reducing VFA accumulation, and stabilizing the syntrophic microbiome. Additionally, mineral additives such as zeolite and magnetite have been shown to adsorb ammonium ions and shift the microbial community toward more ammonia-tolerant consortia.
**2.4 Microbial Dynamics, Reactor Scale-Up, and Economic Outlook**
The performance of fish waste AD is profoundly influenced by inoculum selection. Adapted seeds consistently outperform non-adapted municipal sludge, achieving higher methane yields and faster acclimation. At the reactor scale, continuous and semi-continuous systems are essential for industrial deployment. Innovative designs such as self-agitated anaerobic baffled reactors enhance phase separation and mixing, mitigating the challenges of high-strength fish waste streams. Two-stage configurations that physically separate acidogenesis from methanogenesis are particularly attractive, allowing each stage to operate at its optimal pH and hydraulic retention time (HRT). From an economic perspective, fish waste biogas offers a dual benefit: renewable energy generation and waste stabilization. Economic feasibility analyses indicate that integrated biorefineries producing biogas alongside fertilizer and feed co-products are substantially more viable than single-product pathways. The digestate from fish waste AD is a nutrient-rich organic fertilizer that can close agricultural nutrient loops. Future research should prioritize the development of robust ammonia-tolerant methanogenic consortia, the integration of AD with nutrient recovery technologies (e.g., struvite precipitation), and life cycle assessments (LCA) that quantify the net environmental benefits.
**3. Fish Waste to Fertilizer**
**3.1 Nutrient Composition and Agronomic Value of Fish Waste**
Fish waste is a concentrated nutrient package that can effectively close the loop between seafood processing and agricultural production. The raw material is characterized by high organic nitrogen (proteins, amino acids), substantial phosphorus locked in bones and scales as hydroxyapatite [Ca
5(PO
4)
3OH], and appreciable potassium, calcium, magnesium, and trace micronutrients. Unlike synthetic N-P-K fertilizers, which can acidify soils and deplete organic matter, fish-based amendments release nutrients in a slow, biologically controlled manner that tracks plant demand more closely, thereby improving nutrient use efficiency and reducing off-site losses.
**3.2 Composting and Co-Composting: The Dominant Pathway**
Composting remains the most accessible and widely practiced method for stabilizing fish waste into a land-applicable product. The process relies on thermophilic aerobic decomposition: under proper aeration and moisture management, temperatures reach 50–65 °C over 20–60 days, sufficient to inactivate pathogens and weed seeds while jump-starting the humification process. However, fish waste alone is notoriously difficult to compost due to moisture content around 70–90% and a C/N ratio of 3–7, far below the 25–30 ideal. The solution is co-composting with carbon-rich bulking agents such as straw, sawdust, corn stover, and seaweed. Co-composting with seaweed is a particularly elegant approach: the seaweed absorbs excess moisture, provides complementary potassium and magnesium, and adds a balanced carbon source. Agronomic trials on organic potato crops showed that seaweed-fish compost significantly increased tuber yield and soil microbial biomass. Humic acids extracted from fish-based composts have been shown to enhance lettuce growth by chelating micronutrients and stimulating root plasma membrane H
+-ATPase activity.
**3.3 Liquid Fish Fertilizers: Rapid Nutrient Delivery**
Liquid fish fertilizers, produced through hydrolysis and microbial fermentation, deliver amino acids, short-chain peptides, and soluble minerals directly to plant leaves and roots, bypassing the weeks-to-months mineralization lag typical of solid organics and making them suitable for foliar feeding, drip irrigation, and hydroponic systems. The scaled-up bioconversion of fish waste to liquid fertilizer using a 5 L ribbon-type reactor demonstrated that controlled fermentation can achieve nearly complete liquefaction within a few days. Researchers have identified gut-associated bacteria from earthworm viscera—including *Bacillus* and *Lactobacillus* species—that accelerate protein hydrolysis and suppress spoilage pathogens. Field-level evidence on tomato showed significant improvements in plant height, leaf area, and fruit yield, with performance comparable to or exceeding that of commercial chemical fertilizers.
**3.4 Fish Bone Phosphorus as Fertilizer: Closing the P Cycle**
Perhaps the most strategically important component of fish waste fertilizer is the phosphorus concentrated in bones and scales. With global phosphate rock reserves depleting, recovering phosphorus from organic waste streams is a food security imperative. Fish bones contain phosphorus as hydroxyapatite, which can be converted into a slow-release fertilizer through calcination or low-temperature pyrolysis. The agronomic performance of fish-derived phosphorus is well documented: dewatered fish sludge can match triple superphosphate in use efficiency on certain soils. When fish bones are pyrolyzed, the resulting bone biochar resists phosphorus fixation in acidic soils—a major limitation of conventional water-soluble P fertilizers—and simultaneously improves water retention and provides habitat for beneficial soil microorganisms.
**4. Fish Waste to Biochar**
**4.1 Production and Unique Physicochemical Characteristics**
Biochar derived from fish bones and scales is produced through pyrolysis or carbonization at 400–800 °C under an inert atmosphere (N
2 or limited O
2). The resulting biochar exhibits a distinctive mineralogy compared to lignocellulosic-derived biochars: the natural hydroxyapatite content of fish bones and scales is partially retained during pyrolysis, creating a porous, calcium- and phosphorus-rich carbon matrix with abundant surface functional groups. Higher pyrolysis temperatures generally increase surface area and carbon content but reduce oxygen-containing functional groups. Recent hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) of fish waste offers an alternative for wet feedstocks because it avoids complete pre-drying.
**4.2 Soil Amendment and Phosphorus Delivery**
The primary agronomic application of fish bone biochar lies in its dual function as a soil amendment and a slow-release phosphorus fertilizer. When incorporated into soil, the porous carbon matrix improves water retention, aeration, and cation exchange capacity (CEC), while the embedded calcium phosphate phases release P in a controlled manner that resists fixation in acidic soils. The thermal conversion of fish bones into fertilizers and biostimulants has been demonstrated as a low-tech, circular-economy approach suitable for regions with limited access to synthetic fertilizers. Changes in heavy metal bioavailability from soil amended with biochars further indicate that fish bone biochar can simultaneously stabilize soil contaminants and provide nutrients.
**4.3 Environmental Remediation: Heavy Metal and Organic Pollutant Removal**
Fish waste biochar exhibits exceptional performance in environmental remediation due to its high surface area, phosphate-rich surface chemistry, and abundant functional groups. For heavy metal removal, fishbone and fishbone-derived biochar have demonstrated high adsorption capacities for cadmium, lead, and other toxic metals, with phosphate groups forming stable surface complexes with metal cations. Fish scale biochar has been successfully applied for fluoride removal from groundwater through ion exchange and surface complexation with calcium species, and for uranium extraction via temperature-tuned porous structures. For organic pollutants, tetracycline adsorption by tilapia fish bone-based biochar has been optimized with mass transfer modeling, while fish-scale biochar functionalized with H
3PO
4 showed ultra-efficient adsorption of diclofenac sodium through synergistic surface complexation and pore-filling mechanisms.
**4.4 Catalytic Applications in Advanced Oxidation Processes**
Beyond passive adsorption, fish waste biochar is increasingly recognized as a functional catalyst support and catalyst for advanced oxidation processes (AOPs). The natural N and P content of fish scales enables self-doped, heteroatom-rich carbon frameworks that activate peroxymonosulfate (PMS) and peroxydisulfate to generate reactive sulfate radicals (•SO
4?) and hydroxyl radicals (•OH) for degrading recalcitrant organic pollutants. The transformation of fishbone biowaste into biochar as an efficient persulfate catalyst has been demonstrated, with the phosphate-rich surface facilitating radical generation. Functionalized Fe-N co-doped fishbone biochar has been applied for the remediation of phthalate-contaminated marine sediment, highlighting the potential for in situ environmental remediation.
**5. Fish Waste to Biodiesel**
Fish waste contains 5–30% oil depending on species, rendering it a promising non-edible feedstock for biodiesel production that avoids food-fuel competition. The crude fish waste oil is characterized by high free fatty acid (FFA) content, substantial phospholipids, and a fatty acid profile dominated by long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) such as eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). Oil extraction is typically achieved via pressing, thermal rendering, solvent extraction, or supercritical CO
2. Three dominant process routes have been developed to convert fish waste oil into fatty acid methyl esters (FAME). The acid–base two-step process is the most established route for high-FFA oil: acid esterification with H
2SO
4 reduces FFA to <1 wt%, followed by alkaline transesterification with NaOH or KOH. Heterogeneous catalysis eliminates the need for liquid catalysts; a particularly innovative strategy is the use of calcined fish scales (CaO) as a low-cost, waste-derived solid catalyst, exemplifying true circularity. The supercritical methanol (SCM) process operates at 240–350 °C and 15–30 MPa without any catalyst, achieving rapid conversion regardless of FFA or water content but demanding higher energy input and pressurized equipment. The fuel properties of fish waste biodiesel generally meet international standards (ASTM D6751, EN 14214), though the high unsaturation degree compromises oxidative stability, necessitating antioxidant addition or blending with more saturated feedstocks.
**6. Fish Waste as Feed**
**6.1 Nutritional Potential and Value of Fish Waste as Feedstock**
Fish waste is an exceptionally valuable feedstock for animal nutrition. Unlike plant proteins, fish-derived proteins possess high digestibility (>90% in many species) and favorable essential amino acid ratios that closely match the requirements of fish, poultry, and swine. The lipid fraction is particularly notable for its high concentration of long-chain omega-3 PUFAs (EPA and DHA), which confer immunomodulatory, anti-inflammatory, and growth-promoting properties in farmed animals. However, the rapid autolysis and spoilage of fresh fish waste necessitate immediate preservation through acidification, fermentation, or drying to prevent protein degradation and biogenic amine accumulation.
**6.2 Fish Silage: Preservation, Processing, and Nutritional Quality**
Fish silage is the most widely adopted and cost-effective method for preserving fish waste as a liquid or semi-solid feed ingredient. The process involves acidifying the waste with mineral acids (formic, sulfuric, or propionic acid) or fermenting with lactic acid bacteria (LAB) in the presence of a carbohydrate source to achieve a pH of 3.5–4.5, which inhibits spoilage bacteria while allowing endogenous proteases to hydrolyze proteins into peptides and free amino acids. Properly preserved fish silage maintains nutritional quality for 6–12 months without refrigeration. The use of selected LAB on organic acid accumulation during wet and spray-dried fish-based silages revealed that *Lactobacillus* and *Pediococcus* strains can dominate fermentation, producing sufficient lactic acid to suppress pathogens while preserving protein integrity.
**6.3 Fish Protein Hydrolysate and Functional Feed Applications**
Beyond simple preservation, enzymatic or acid hydrolysis of fish waste can produce fish protein hydrolysate (FPH), a highly digestible, bioactive ingredient containing small peptides and free amino acids. Studies on Japanese sea bass demonstrated that FPH supplementation enhanced lysozyme activity and disease resistance. Fermented hydrolysate could effectively replace fishmeal in juvenile barramundi diets while improving gut histology and antioxidant status. Fish waste-derived feeds have been successfully applied across a broad taxonomic range including Mozambique tilapia, South African abalone, broiler chickens, pigs, Omani sheep, Japanese quails, and Pacific white shrimp. In crustacean aquaculture, moderate replacement levels of fishmeal by fish silage (up to 25–30%) could be achieved without compromising growth, with mTOR signaling pathways implicated in the growth response.
**7. Fish Waste to Other High-Value Products**
**7.1 Collagen, Gelatin and Bioactive Peptides**
Fish skin and scales represent one of the most valuable and underutilized sources of collagen and gelatin. Unlike mammalian-derived collagen, marine fish collagen is free from religious constraints, exhibits lower immunogenicity, and possesses a unique amino acid composition rich in glycine, proline, and hydroxyproline. The protective effect of gelatin and gelatin hydrolysate from salmon skin on UV irradiation-induced photoaging of mice skin demonstrated that marine collagen peptides can inhibit matrix metalloproteinase activity and promote dermal collagen synthesis. Atlantic salmon co-product-derived protein hydrolysates have been identified as a source of antidiabetic peptides, with in vitro and in vivo studies showing dipeptidyl peptidase-IV (DPP-IV) inhibitory activity comparable to commercial antidiabetic drugs. The valorization of aquaculture by-products of salmonids to produce enzymatic hydrolysates has demonstrated that process optimization can yield peptides with confirmed antioxidant, antihypertensive, and antimicrobial activities.
**7.2 Chitin, Enzymes and Marine Bioactive Compounds**
Fish scales are rich in chitin, a natural polysaccharide that can be deacetylated to chitosan, an invaluable biopolymer with extensive applications in water treatment, food preservation, agriculture, and biomedicine. The natural calcification of fish scales (calcium phosphate-chitin composite) offers unique advantages for bone tissue engineering scaffolds and controlled-release drug delivery systems. Fish waste is also a source of industrial enzymes: fish scales have been identified as a potential substrate for the production of alkaline protease and amino acid-rich aqua hydrolysate by *Bacillus altitudinis*.
**7.3 Advanced Materials and Non-Traditional Applications**
Beyond biological and chemical products, fish waste has found innovative applications in construction and advanced materials science. Recycling fish scale powder in improving the performance of asphalt has been explored, with scales acting as a natural polymer modifier that improves rheological properties, rutting resistance, and thermal stability. A sustainable approach to scalable production of a graphene-based flame retardant using waste fish deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) has been reported, exploiting the high phosphorus and nitrogen content of fish DNA to create advanced carbon materials.
**8. Cross-Pathway Comparison, Route Selection, and Sustainability Trade-Offs**
No single valorization pathway is universally preferable. Route selection should balance the biochemical composition and hygienic quality of the waste against product value, capital intensity, energy and chemical demand, scale, local infrastructure, and market access. Clean and fresh protein-rich fractions can justify feed or high-value protein recovery; lipid-rich streams favor oil extraction and biodiesel; dilute, mixed, or lower-value putrescible organics are better suited to AD; bone- and scale-rich fractions favor phosphorus recovery, biochar, or collagen/mineral materials. LCA is therefore needed to quantify burden shifting across waste collection, transport, preprocessing, conversion, energy use, chemicals, emissions, and product substitution. Techno-economic analysis (TEA) should complement LCA by reporting capital expenditure, operating expenditure, feedstock logistics, and product revenues. Existing economic analyses show that integrated biorefineries can outperform single-product systems, but profitability is strongly dependent on local product prices and policy assumptions.
**9. Challenges and Future Prospects**
Despite extensive research on fish waste valorization, several challenges hinder industrial-scale implementation. For biogas production, ammonia inhibition remains the primary technical barrier, requiring advanced reactor designs and bioaugmentation with tolerant microbial consortia. For biodiesel, the high unsaturation and FFA content of fish waste oil necessitate complex pretreatment or specialized catalysts. For feed applications, the risk of biogenic amine accumulation and seasonal variability of supply pose challenges for consistent product quality. Future research should prioritize: (1) process integration through multi-product biorefineries that synergistically combine biogas, biodiesel, feed, fertilizer, and biochar production; (2) advanced pretreatment including microwave, ultrasonic, and enzyme-assisted methods; (3) circular economy metrics through comprehensive LCA and TEA; (4) policy and regulation establishing quality standards for fish waste-derived products; and (5) high-value product extraction using green chemistry approaches such as deep eutectic solvents and supercritical fluids.
**10. Conclusions**
Fish waste represents a significant and underutilized resource that can be converted into a diverse array of energy carriers and value-added products through biological, thermal, and chemical processes. AD offers a mature pathway for biogas production, constrained by ammonia inhibition that can be mitigated through co-digestion and biochar addition. Composting and hydrolysis produce nutrient-dense fertilizers supporting sustainable agriculture. Biochar derived from fish bones and scales exhibits exceptional adsorption and catalytic properties due to its unique phosphate-rich mineral composition. Biodiesel production is technically feasible, though economic viability depends on catalyst development and process integration. Fish silage and protein hydrolysates remain important feed ingredients requiring further optimization of quality control and preservation technologies. The extraction of collagen, gelatin, and bioactive peptides represents the highest-value valorization pathway, though scalability and cost remain significant barriers. The future of fish waste management lies in integrated biorefineries that combine multiple conversion pathways to maximize resource recovery and minimize environmental impact. By transitioning from linear waste disposal to circular bioeconomy models, the seafood industry can simultaneously reduce pollution, generate renewable energy, and create valuable products, enhancing the resilience and sustainability of the global seafood industry.